looking a trojan horse in the mouth: problematizing philosophy for/with children's hope for social reform through the history of race and education in the us
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12957/childphilo.2024.80069Keywords:
philosophy for children, race and racism, critical race theory, philosophy in public schools, educational reformAbstract
Many P4/WC practitioners and theorists privilege the school as a space for thinking and practicing philosophy for/with children. Despite its coercive nature, thinkers such as Jana Mohr Lone, David Kennedy, and Nancy Vansieleghem argue that P4C is a Trojan horse intended to reform the education system from within. I argue, however, that the Trojan horse argument requires us to internalize an incomplete and historically decontextualized understanding of public schools that in turn can reify histories of white supremacy within our CPIs – a consequence that can be particularly harmful when practicing P4C with minority youth. To accurately adjudicate the value of public school classrooms for P4C – especially for those CPIs whose members are primarily Black, Latinx, Indigenous, or other youth of color — I contextualize the Trojan horse argument in the history of race and education in the United States. Through this historical analysis, I conclude that the reformist position becomes increasingly more untenable and that the material history of race and education in fact supports a pessimistic understanding of P4C in education. I end by reflecting on P4C’s need to rethink its privileging of schools as a primary site for philosophical inquiry and caution practitioners against using “social progress” as a justification for how and where they practice their craft. Instead, I encourage them to rethink how and where they practice P4C, based on the local historical and material conditions of the participants.
References
Bell, D. (2004). Silent Covenants: Brown V. Board of Education and the Unfulfilled Hopes for Racial Reform. Oxford University Press.
Bell, D. A. (1992). Faces at the Bottom of the Well: The Permanence of Racism. BasicBooks.
Biesta, G. (2011). Philosophy, Exposure, and Children: How to Resist the Instrumentalisation of Philosophy in Education. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 45(2), 305–319.
Carter, R. L. (1968). The Warren Court and Desegregation. Michigan Law Review, 67(2), 237–248.
Chetty, D. (2014). The Elephant in The Room: Picturebooks, Philosophy for Children and Racism. Childhood and Philosophy. 10(19), 11–31.
Chetty, D. (2018). Racism as ‘Reasonableness’: Philosophy for Children and the Gated Community of Inquiry. 13(1), 39–54.
Curry, T. J. (2008). Saved by the Bell: Derrick Bell’s Racial Realism as Pedagogy. Philosophical Studies in Education. 39, 35–46.
Curry, T. J. (2021). Racism and The Equality Delusion. Iai News. https://iai.tv/articles/racism-and-the-equality-delusion-auid-1836
Dewey, J. (2017). The School and Society. Chicago University Pres. https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/53910/pg53910-images.html
Dotson, K. (2012). How Is This Paper Philosophy? Comparative Philosophy, 3(1), 3–29.
Florida Department of Education. (2023). Florida’s State Academic Standards – Social Studies, 2023. Disponible in: https://www.fldoe.org/core/fileparse.php/20653/urlt/6-4.pdf
Foucault, M. (1972). The Discourse on Language. In The Archeology of Knowledge. Pantheon. 215–237.
Hill-Collins, P. (2009). Another Kind of Public Education Race, Schools, the Media, and Democratic Possibilities. Beacon Press: Boston, MA.
Kennedy, N. S., & Kennedy, D. S. (2011). Community of Philosophical Inquiry as a Discursive Structure, and Its Role in School Curriculum Design. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 45(2), 265–283.
Kennedy, D. (2009). Another World is Possible: Schooling, Multitude, and Philosophy for Children. In Children Philosophize Worldwide: Theoretical and Practical Concepts. Peter Lang. 47–62.
Kennedy, N. S. (2005) The Role of Paradox in Argumentation and Concept Transformation in aCommunity of Mathematical Inquiry: A Dialectical Analysis. UMI Dissertation Publishing,UMI ID: 921046091
Kronsted, C., & Wurtz, J. (2021). Philosophical Horizons: P4/WC and Anti-Racism in Memphis, TN. Intentional Disruptions: Expanding Access to Philosophy. 91-112.
Lawson, B. (2013). Philosophical Blacknuss. The Black Scholar. 43(4), 86–93.
Lipman, M. (1982). Philosophy for Children. Thinking: The Journal of Philosophy for Children, 3(3–4), 35–44.
Lipman, Matthew. (1988). Philosophy goes to school. Temple University Press.
Lipman, M. (2003). Thinking in education. Cambridge University Press.
Lipman, M. (2011). Philosophy for Children: Some Assumptions and Implications. ETHICS IN PROGRESS, 2(1), 3–16. https://doi.org/10.14746/EIP.2011.1.2
Lone, J. M. (2002). Does Philosophy for Children Belong in School at All? Analytic Teaching, 21(2). https://journal.viterbo.edu/index.php/at/article/view/838
Long, F. (2005). Thomas Reid and Philosophy with Children. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 39(4), 599–614.
Lushyn, P. (2002) The Paradoxical Nature of Facilitation in Community of Inquiry, Analytic Teaching , 24.2, pp. 110-115.
Lushyn, P. & Kennedy, D. (2000) The Psychodynamics of Community of Inquiry and EducationalReform: A Cross-Cultural Perspective. Thinking: The Journal of Philosophy for Children, 15.3, pp. 9-16cKee, D. (2006). Tusk Tusk. Andersen Press.
Mills, C. W. (1997). The Racial Contract. t. Cornell University Press.
Mills, C. W. (2007). White Ignorance. In Shannon Sullivan & Nancy Tuana (Ed.), Race and Epistemologies of Ignorance. State University of New York Press. 11–38.
Murris, K. (2009). A Philosophical Approach to Emotions: Understanding love´s knowledge through a frog in love. Childhood and Philosophy, 5(9), 5–30.
Nietzsche, F. W. (2006). Twilight of the Idols. The Nietzsche Reader (K. Ansell-Pearson & D. Large, Eds.). Blackwell Publishing. 456-485.
Reed-Sandoval, A. (2016). Who Talks? Who Listens? Taking Positionality Seriously in Philosophy for Children In S. M. Meagher, S. Noll, & J. S. Biehl (Eds.), Routledge International Handbook for Philosophy for Children. Routledge. 219–226
Reed-Sandoval, A. (2019). Can Philosophy for Children Contribute to Decolonization? Precollege Philosophy and Public Practice, 1, 27–41.
Rufo, C. F. (2023). America’s cultural revolution: How the radical left conquered everything. Harper Collins.
Rufo, C. F. (2021). Christopher F. Rufo’s March 10, 2021 Tweet. https://archive.li/1F25m
Sharp, A. M. (1986). Is there an Essence of Education? Journal of Moral Education, 15(3), 189–196
Torrey, J. (2020). Reaching Out to the Underrepresented: An Interview with John R. Torrey. In S. M. Meagher, S. Noll, & J. S. Biehl (Eds.), Routledge Handbook of Philosophy of the City. Routledge. 407–411.
UCLA Law School CRT Forward. (2023). CRT Forward Tracking Project – Tracking anti-CRT efforts introduced at the local, state, and federal levels. https://crtforward.law.ucla.edu/
Vansieleghem, N. (2005). Philosophy for Children as the Wind of Thinking. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 39(1), 19–35.
Vansieleghem, N., & Kennedy, D. (2011). What is Philosophy for Children, What is Philosophy with Children—After Matthew Lipman? Journal of Philosophy of Education, 45(2), 171–182.
Vitale, S. (2021). Overcoming Barriers: Pre-College Philosophy Programs in Neoliberalism. In S. K. Miller (Ed.), Intentional Disruption: Expanding Access to Philosophy. Vernon Press. 113–130.
Yeager, D. S., Purdie-Vaughns, V., Hooper, S. Y., & Cohen, G. L. (2017). Loss of Institutional Trust Among Racial and Ethnic Minority Adolescents: A Consequence of Procedural Injustice and a Cause of Life-Span Outcomes. Child Development, 88(2), 658–676.
