teacher and learner perspectives on philosophical discussion – uncertainty as a challenge and opportunity

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.12957/childphilo.2019.42675

Keywords:

uncertainty, theory of education, philosophizing

Abstract

We investigated teachers' and children's experiences of philosophy with children by analysing the content of interviews with primary school teachers and discussions with groups of primary school pupils. The results show that regular philosophy sessions with children can have an impact on teachers’ view of themselves as educators, their approach to teaching and their personal development. From the children’s point of view, the most important and meaningful aspect, aside from the content of philosophical discussion, was the opportunity to think together in an open-ended way. A key component of the collective construction of meaning was uncertainty, which is an integral feature of philosophical discussion. These findings link with the idea of “citizen as agent” in a variety of ways. Philosophising with children leads to a more collaborative and democratic teaching style, giving children the space to bring their own interests and activities to the discussion. This aligns with pupils’ enjoyment of the openness and uncertainty of philosophical issues, their appreciation of the opportunity to engage with different ideas and viewpoints, and their willingness to rise to the challenge of revising their own positions and changing their thinking.

Author Biography

kerstin heike michalik, University of Hamburg

Professor of Educational Science

References

Barrow, W. (2015). „I think she’s learnt how to sort of let the class peak“. An exploratory study of children’s perspectives on P4C as participatory pedagogy. In Thinking skills and creativity, 17, p. 76-87.

Fair, F., et al. (2015). Socrates in the Schools from Scotland to Texas. Replication a study on the effects of a Philosophy for Children program. In Journal of Philosophy in Schools, 2/1, p. 18-37.

Flick, Uwe (2016). Qualitative Sozialforschung. Eine Einführung. 7th Edition. Reinbek bei Hamburg.

Gaparatou, R. & Erganzaki, M. (2015). Stundents’ Views about Their Participation in a Philosophy Program. In Creative Education, 6, p. 726-737.

Gorard, S., Siddiqui, N., & See, B. H. (2015). Philosophy for Children. Evaluation Report and Executive Summary. School of Education. Durham University.

Haller, T. (2015). Philosophieren mit Kindern im Fachunterricht. Eine empirische Untersuchung zu Erfahrungen und Einstellungen von Lehrerinnen und Lehrern. Masterarbeit im Studiengang Lehramt Primar- und Sekundarstufe. Universität Hamburg.

Helsper, W. (1996). Antinomien des Lehrerhandelns in modernisierten pädagogischen Kulturen. Paradoxe Verwendungsweisen von Autonomie und Selbstverantwortlichkeit. In A. Combe, W. Helsper (Ed.). Pädagogische Professionalität. Untersuchungen zum Typus pädagogischen Handelns, p. 521-569.

Helsper, W. (2001). Antinomien des Lehrerhandelns – Anfragen an die Bildungsgangdidaktik. In U. Hericks/J. Keuffer/H.-Ch. Kräft/I. Kunze (Ed.). Bildungsgangdidaktik. Perspektiven für Fachunterricht und Lehrerbildung. Opladen.

Helzel, G. (2018). Kindliche Entwicklungsprozesse beim Philosophieren. Eine empirische Studie zu Ungewissheit und Mehrperspektivität. Opladen, Berlin, Toronto.

Helzel, G./Michalik, K. (2015). Kindliche Entwicklungsprozesse beim Philosophieren mit Kindern. Eine empirische Untersuchung zu Mehr-Perspektivität und Ungewissheitstoleranz. In: H.-J. Fischer/H. Giest/K. Michalik (Ed.): Bildung im und durch Sachunterricht. Bad Heilbrunn, p. 189-196.

Jenkins, J. (1986). Philosophy for Children Programme at a Gloucestershire Cemprehensive School in Great Britain. In Thinking. The Journal of Philosphy for Children, 6, 3, p.33-37.

Jeschke, S. (Ed.) (2013). Exploring Uncertainty. Ungewissheit und Unsicherheit im interdisziplinären Diskurs. Wiesbaden.

Koller, H.C. (2012): Bildung anders denken. Einführung in die Theorie transformatorischer Bildungsprozesse. Stuttgart.

Mayring, P. (2015). Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse. Grundlagen und Techniken. 12., revised edition. Weinheim und Basel. Beltz.

Michalik, K. (2012). Interviews mit Lehrkräften und Gruppendiskussionen mit Kindern zu Wahrnehmungen und Bewertungen des Philosophierens mit Kindern. Forschungsprojekt an der Fakultät für Erziehungswissenschaft der Universität Hamburg.

Michalik, Kerstin (2015): Philosophische Gespräche mit Kindern als Medium für Bildungsprozesse im Sachunterricht. In Bildung im und durch Sachunterricht. In H.-J. Fischer/H. Giest/K. Michalik. Bad Heilbrunn. p. 175 – 182.

Michalik, K. (2018). Empirische Forschung zu Wirkungen philosophischer Gespräche mit Kindern. In. H. de Boer, K. Michalik (Ed.). Philosophieren mit Kindern - Forschungszugänge und -perspektiven. Opladen, Berlin, Toronto, p. 13-32.

Pálsson, H. (1996). We Think More than Before about Others and their Opinions. An Evaluation Report from Iceland. In. Thinking and Reasoning 12, p. 24-28.

Pfeiffer, S. (2013). Das Unterrichtsfach Philosophieren mit Kinder in MecklenburgVorpommern. In Pädagogische Rundschau 67, 6, p. 651-669.

Scholl, R. (2014). „Inside-out Pedagogy“. Theorising Pedagogical Transformation through Teaching Philosophy. In Australian Journal of Teaching Philosophy, 39/6), p. 89-106.

Siddiqui, N., Gorard, S., See, B. H. (2017). Non-cognitive impacts of Philosophy for Children. School of Education Durham University.

Scholl, R./Nichols, Kim/Burgh, Gilbert (2014). Transforming pedagogy through philosophical inquiry. In. International Journal of Pedagogies and Learning, 9/3, p. 253-272.

Scholl, Rosie/Nichols, K./Burgh, G. (2016). Connecting learning to the world beyond the classroom through collaborative philosophical inquiry. In. Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education, 44/5, p. 436-454.

Topping, Keith J./Trickey, Steve (2007). Collaborative Philosophical Enquiry for School children. Participant Evaluation at 11 Years, in. Thinking. The Journal of Philosophy for Children 18/3, p. 23-34.

Downloads

Published

2019-06-11

How to Cite

michalik, kerstin heike. (2019). teacher and learner perspectives on philosophical discussion – uncertainty as a challenge and opportunity. Childhood & Philosophy, 15, 01–20. https://doi.org/10.12957/childphilo.2019.42675

Issue

Section

dossier: philosophical inquiry with children: new voices