O CONSEQUENCIALISMO JURÍDICO À BRASILEIRA: NOTAS PARA UM ESTUDO DO FENÔMENO / "BRAZILIAN" LEGAL CONSEQUENTIALISM: A PRELIMINARY STUDY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12957/rfd.2022.71724Keywords:
Teoria do direito. Pragmatismo filosófico. Pragmatismo jurídico. Interpretação / Legal theory. Philosophical pragmatism. Legal pragmatism. Legal interpretation.Abstract
Resumo: De início o texto apresenta uma definição de ´consequencialismo jurídico´, tal como a categoria vem frequentando a dogmática jurídica e decisões judiciais recentes. Logo em seguida, questiona-se sobre o lugar do argumento e sua relativa imprecisão em relação ao pragmatismo/consequencialismo filosófico. Então, o texto cogita de três razões pelas quais o consequencialismo jurídico – já aqui entendido à brasileira, isto é, tal como praticado nas cortes e expressado na literatura dogmática nacional – obteve certo êxito. Por fim, o texto indica algumas críticas internas ao consequencialismo/pragmatismo à brasileira, e, também, algumas das possíveis respostas a ela, e, então, cogita de dois possíveis futuros para o argumento.
Palavras-chave: Teoria do direito. Pragmatismo filosófico. Pragmatismo jurídico. Interpretação.
Abstract: The paper presents a simple definition of ´legal consequentialism´, as used in current legal literature and legal opinions. Then, it asks about the meaning of the expression and criticizes some loose uses of it, specifically when compared to a much more precise definition of ´philosophical consequentialism/pragmatism´. In its third part the study discusses three reasons of ´legal consequentialism´ success story in Brazil. In the end, the paper brings some internal critique on ´legal consequentialism´ and some possible answers to them. As some closing thoughts, the study discusses two possible futures for ´legal consequentialism´ as understood by Brazilian courts and legal literature.
Keywords: Legal theory. Philosophical pragmatism. Legal pragmatism. Legal interpretation.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright
oArticles published in the Revista da Faculdade de Direito da UERJ (RFD/UERJ)
The copyrights of the published articles belong to the Revista da Faculdade de Direito da UERJ (RFD/UERJ). Total or partial reproduction of the articles is allowed as long as the source is cited.
oPartial reproduction from other publications
Submitted papers that contain parts of text extracted from other publications must obey the specified limits to ensure originality of the submitted work. Plagiarism in all its forms constitutes unethical behavior and is unacceptable.
It is recommended to avoid reproduction of tables and illustrations from other publications. The article that contains reproduction of one or more tables and/or illustrations from other publications will only be sent for analysis if it is accompanied by written permission from the copyright holder of the original work for the specified reproduction in the Revista da Faculdade de Direito da UERJ (RFD/UERJ). The permission must be addressed to the author of the submitted work. Under no circumstances will the Journal of the Law School of the State University of Rio de Janeiro (RFD/UERJ) and the authors of the papers published in this journal transfer the rights thus obtained.
•The refused studies will be returned to the authors, if asked.
The Revista da Faculdade de Direito is licensed under a Creative Commons Atribuição 4.0 Internacional License.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons 4.0 Attribution-No Derivation License.
This license allows copying and redistribution of the material in any medium or format for any purpose, even commercial, provided that the original authorship is acknowledged.