Prophecies of Fraud: unacceptable marriages and dangerous subjects in judicial decisions about rectification of transsexual people’s “sex”

Authors

  • Luiza Ferreira Lima Universidade de São Paulo Programa de Pós-Graduação em Antropologia Social

Keywords:

gender, transsexuality, Courts of Justice, State, marriage

Abstract

This paper investigates representations and values underlying the mobilization of a recurrent argument in judicial decisions that evaluate rectification requests for the category “sex” in identification documents, demanded by transsexual people: that a probable future marriage between the plaintiff and a third party would mean the former is misleading the latter. Through the analysis of decisions elaborated by magistrates in several Brazilian State Courts, from 2000 to 2014, I noticed: a) the production of meanings of legally possible and legitimate marriage and family; b) the formation of suspicion around transsexual people, viewed as dangerous and potentially deceitful; c) the concomitant creation of good-faith individual and collective victims that would be potentially deceived; d) the mobilization of time dimensions as a way of crystallizing normative patterns of gender and of materializing future threats.

Author Biography

Luiza Ferreira Lima, Universidade de São Paulo Programa de Pós-Graduação em Antropologia Social

É bacharel em Direito pela Universidade de São Paulo. Mestra e doutoranda em Antropologia Social pela mesma Universidade. Membro do Coletivo de Estudos de Corpo e Cidade (COCCIX/NAU/USP) e do Núcleo de Estudos dos Marcadores Sociais da Diferença (NUMAS/USP). Atua principalmente nos seguintes temas de pesquisa: gênero, transexualidades, travestilidades e transgeneridades, discursos e políticas.

Published

2017-04-29

Issue

Section

Articles