peter pan: the leader and his followers an experience of philosophy with children

esther charabati

Abstract


Philosophy and literature are linked by strong ties that are evident in both disciplines: there are numerous literary and philosophical works in which reciprocal influences can be traced. This philosophical experience with children started from a classic work, Peter Pan, to motivate elementary school students. The goals were a) to develop critical thinking skills and ethical problematization around school issues; b) to develop analysis, synthesis, inferring, debate, questioning, and creative thinking skills; and c) for students to make connections between their daily experiences and the situations discussed in the story. Peter Pan portrays a popular kind of character of our times: the leader. Peter is smart and friendly, possesses enough courage and charisma to entice lost children, the Red Skins, and Wendy and her siblings. His imagination and passion for adventure make him even more appealing. Peter also embodies flaws commonly seen in numerous leaders: vanity, selfishness, and lack of responsibility. To exert control he relies on the submission of lost children. While both behaviors may seem natural to us in the story, in real life at school we would label them with words like bullying, abuse, aggression, victims... This experience showed that literary works can trigger deep thinking and debate in students that apply to dilemmas in both school and everyday life; it prompted questioning regarding relationships and points of view; it was also possible to appreciate the possibilities that this space opened to encourage imagination. Educators could witness and see evidence of the power of questioning even though only a few of them had learned these skills. Limited background in critical thinking reduces the ability to implement strategies that contribute to the growth of the above mentioned skills.


Keywords


education; ethics; bullying; literature

References


Agratti, L.V. (2016) “La práctica de la filosofía en la educación y el propósito de que cada vez sean más los que se representen el mundo como propio”. En: Kohan, W.O., Lopes S. y Martins, F. (orgs.) O ato de educar em uma língua ainda por ser escrita, Rio de Janeiro: Nefi.

Álvarez, J.P (2015) “No hay quien pueda pensar por otro”. Entrevista a Walter O. Kohan. En: J. E. Pérez, J.P. Álvarez y C. Guerra Eds.), Hacer filosofía con niños y niñas. Entre educación y filosofía. Valparaíso: Universidad de Valparaíso.

Barrie, J, M. (2002). Peter Pan. Barcelona, España: José J. de Olañeta. Ed.

Charabati, E. (2006). Los amigos de Peter Pan. México: Fundación para la Educación Colegio Hebreo Maguén David.

Defrance, B. (2005): Disciplina en la escuela, España, Ed. Morata.

Hawken, J. (2016). Philosopher avec les enfants : enquête théorique et expérimentale sur une pratique de l’ouverture d’esprit [Filosofar con los niños: encuesta teórica y experimental sobre una práctica e la apertura de espíritu] (Tesis doctoral). Paris: Université Panthéon-Sorbonne, Paris.

Kohlberg, L., Power, F. y Higgins, A. (1997). La educación moral. España: Gedisa.

Lipman, M, Sharp, A.M. y Oscayan, F.S. (1992). La filosofía en el aula. Madrid: Ediciones de la Torre.

Maulini, Olivier (1998). “La question: un universel mal partagé”, en: Educateur, n°7, p.13-20. Recuperado de https://archive-ouverte.unige.ch/unige:35542.

Maulini, O. (2005). Questionner pour enseigner & pour apprendre. Le rapport au savoir dans la classe. Paris: ESF.

Skliar, C. (2017). Pedagogías de las diferencias. Bs. AS: Noveduc.

Tozzi, M. (1999). Apprendre a philosopher au cours de morale, Bruxelles: Entre-vues.

Tozzi, M. (2008). Pensar por sí mismo: iniciación a la pedagogía de la filosofía. Madrid: Editorial Popular.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.12957/childphilo.2019.42479

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


childhood & philosophy Creative Commons License
e-issn 1984-5987 | p-issn 2525-5061